What Does Science Really Tell Us About Mary Magdalene relics?

3D photogrammetric model of the skull traditionally attributed to Mary Magdalene, presented during a scientific conference in Saint-Maximin-la-Sainte-Baume.
Between faith, tradition, history and science, the story of Mary Magdalene’s relics is more complex — and more fascinating — than a simple “true or false.”

I had the privilege of attending a conference in Saint-Maximin-la-Sainte-Baume with Dr. Philippe Charlier, the French forensic scientist and anthropologist who has been studying the relics attributed to Mary Magdalene.
It was an opportunity to revisit a question that often provokes very strong reactions:

Are the relics in Saint-Maximin really those of Mary Magdalene?

The honest answer is: science cannot prove this with certainty. But neither has science demonstrated that they cannot be hers. And this distinction matters.

A face reconstructed from the skull

A few years ago, Dr. Charlier and his team carried out a detailed forensic and anthropological study of the skull preserved in the Basilica of Saint-Maximin.
They could not removed from its reliquary, ut they took almost 400 high-resolution photographs, allowing the researchers to create a detailed 3D model and a forensic facial reconstruction.
The result was the face we now often associate with Mary Magdalene.
Of course, this is not a portrait of Mary Magdalene.
It is a scientific reconstruction of the face corresponding to the skull that has been preserved and venerated in Saint-Maximin for centuries.

The researchers also examined a preserved strand of hair, using microscopy and electron microscopy. Their observations provided further material information about the relic.
The study was published in a scientific journal in 2019, with the researchers stressing that further investigations would be necessary.

In other words, they did not claim to have scientifically “identified” Mary Magdalene. But they did not conclude that the relic was a medieval fabrication either.

And what about Vézelay?

This is where the story becomes particularly intriguing.

For centuries, both Vézelay in Burgundy and Saint-Maximin in Provence laid claim to the relics of Mary Magdalene
The two traditions have different histories.
In 1279, Charles II discovered a tomb at Saint-Maximin and identified as that of Mary Magdalene. The discovery became a major turning point in the history of her cult in Provence.

During the conference, Dr. Charlier was also asked about the relics preserved at Vézelay.
His answer was brief but intriguing: the bone density of the remains at Vézelay was not the same as that observed in the Saint-Maximin remains.
He did not elaborate further during the conference, and I have not found a published scientific study providing comparative measurements of the two sets of remains.

So I would not draw a conclusion from this observation alone. But it is certainly a question worth investigating further.

What can we honestly say today?

The investigation did not stop with the skull. Researchers also examined a lock of hair traditionally associated with Mary Magdalene, using high-powered microscopes and chemical analysis.
The hair found to be naturally dark brown, with reddish areas. More intriguingly, its surface contained traces of clay and microscopic remains of diatoms — tiny algae whose siliceous structures can survive for very long periods.
The researchers suggested that the hair may have been treated with this clay-rich substance, perhaps for cleansing or cosmetic purposes — a practice known in Mediterranean and African traditions.

The possibility of cleansing is particularly evocative when we consider the Provençal tradition of Mary Magdalene’s years of retreat in the cave of Sainte-Baume.
Could she used the clay as part of her personal care in such a setting? While science cannot answer this question, the hypothesis offers a fascinating point of connection between the material evidence and the landscape in which tradition places her final years.

These findings do not, by themselves, establish the identity of the person to whom the hair belonged. These findings reveal fascinating details about the hair’s composition, treatment and age. Yet many questions remain, and each scientific result deserves careful consideration.

What can the skull tell us about the woman behind the tradition?

The anthropological examination carried out in 1974, and revisited during the later forensic study led by Dr. Philippe Charlier, concluded that the skull belonged to a woman of Mediterranean origin, who was probably between 50 and 60 years old at the time of her death.

These findings are intriguing because they are compatible with the traditional image of Mary Magdalene as a woman who lived to an advanced age. However, these findings cannot confirm her identity, and radiocarbon dating has yet to establish the skull’s age.
The research offers valuable clues about the woman behind the centuries-old tradition, but it cannot prove that she was Mary Magdalene.

The question of her identity remains open — inviting us to continue exploring the meeting point between scientific investigation, historical tradition and faith.